Not Everyone Believes, Ross Douthat
A religion is a choice.
The people who try to sell you on religion, they love to tell you that it's not a choice, that it's just the Truth, that they aren't selling you anything, that you just have to accept that what they're saying is true and you have to take it for good or for bad.
That's what Ross Douthat is writing about at the end of his book. The book is Believe: Why Everyone Should Be Religious.
That's what Ross Douthat is trying to sell. He’s trying to sell it as if he's not selling it, as if he's just trying to give you advice about the Truth.
We're just a few pages from the end of this book now.
This podcast that you're listening to is called Not Everyone Believes Ross Douthat, because honestly, a huge number of people don't believe. About forty percent of the American population are non-Christian. Thirty percent of Americans are non-religious. One out of three Americans are not religious at all.
Ross Douthat is telling us that we all should believe, that we should belong to religion.
Here at the end of his book, Douthat is trying to make it sound like there's a hard truth within religion, but we just have to take it, even though we don't want it to be true. It's what we have to accept.
He's trying to make it sound responsible, as if we’re taking a tough medicine that just tastes awful, but it's gonna make us healthy in the end. Ross Douthat writes that he he would love to have a more forgiving, accepting, loving religion, than what Christianity actually is.
What Christianity actually is? Let's listen to some of the words that he's using here in the last few pages of the last chapter of his book to describe Christianity:
authority
condemnation
anathema
existential angst
risk
judgment
responsibility
spiritual dangers
stark burdens
fearful and hard
demonic powers
brusque warnings from Jesus
the narrow gate
the eye of the needle
the wide path to destruction
condemned goats, condemned to eternal punishment.
Ross Douthat doesn’t get this harsh, unforgiving tone from nowhere. That's what the Gospels of Jesus talk about. Jesus himself talks about people as if they're animals.
Jesus condemns people not just to punishment, but to punishment forever and ever, for the momentary choices they make in a limited life. That's not justice. That's not love. That's not responsibility. It's punishment for the love of punishment.
Ross Douthat writes that it's so hard, but he has to accept this religion because it's the one Truth according to which everything in life, has to be reinterpreted. That's an idea we explored in the last episode, the previous episode of this podcast. I encourage you to go back and listen to that.
Ross Douthat writes: “I have never found the son of man as reassuring a character as some Christians do.”
The Son of Man is, of course, Jesus. Ross Douthat is saying that Jesus is kind of a hard ass, but that's just how it's got to be.
Ross Douthat chooses to embrace that hard ass, that punishing character, that unforgiving, unloving, vengeful, violent, judgmental, angry, fear-inducing Jesus.
That's who is in the Gospels, after all, at the end. You can take some of those nice words, but if you take a look at what else Jesus did in the end, Jesus turned out to be hard, to be cruel, to be nasty in pursuit of his own power.
Ross Douthat writes further:
“What brings Jesus especially, that cuts across my temperament, is a special sort of urgency. A sense that there are not, in fact, eons of potentially reincarnated existence or innumerable stages of an afterlife in which to work out our destiny, nor a guarantee that the divine desire to reconcile all things will triumph over our own rebellion, no matter how far we go astray.”
The question that's in my mind as I read Ross Douthat describe the cruel, nasty, vengeful Jesus of his chosen religion is this: Why did Ross Douthat choose this? Why did he choose to go along with this religion?
He's phrasing it in terms of regret that, he sure would like things to be different, but they aren't. That's kind of giving himself an excuse, isn't it? It's saying he didn't really have a choice. It’s using the excuse that Ross Douthat just found the Truth and that's just how things have to be.
The truth is, Ross Douthat never even looked elsewhere to see if some kind of truth might lie elsewhere. Ross Douthat never looked outside of Christianity. He never tried any other religion. He never tried being an atheist. Not once in his life.
He was a Catholic by the time he was a teenager. He grew up as a Protestant. He's always been a Christian, his entire life. It's how he was raised, and he never tried to look outside of that.
That is a choice.
Ross Douthat writes that he knows his religion is cruel, judgmental, dangerous, that it has a god who has created demonic powers that hurt people, created evil. Knowing that, Ross Douthat goes for it. He chooses this cruel god to worship.
Why is that? What is that choice for?
The choice that Ross Douthat is describing in the closing argument of his book is a love of punishment, a love of hurting other people because they disagree with you. That's the ultimate message of his religion.
Ross Douthat writes:
“We are being given warning after warning not to let this moment go to waste because our life could be demanded of us at any moment because at the hour we least expect it, the master could unexpectedly return.”
The final words that Ross Douthat writes in this book are a threat:
“When the rooster crows, or in the morning, lest he come suddenly and find you asleep, if you are this sleeper, I beg of you, awake.”
Ross Douthat writes in celebration of cruelty: “but from the one who has not, even what he has will be taken away.”
So many of these quotes, so many of these selections, like the narrow gate, the eye of the needle, the wide path to destruction, have to do with a series of verses in the Gospels of the New Testament of Christianity that center around the idea that Jesus is the master of the house, and he is going to return. He could return at any time, and if you aren't ready, meaning if you are not shown to be in obedience to the master of the house of Jesus, then you are going to be very, very sorry for that mistake. You're going to be made sorry because you're going to be punished.
How are you going to be punished? Well, Jesus says how himself in the Gospel of Matthew, chapter 24.
“As the days of Noah were, so shall the coming of the Son of Man be. The Lord of that slave shall come in a day when he looks not for him, and in an hour that he is not aware of and shall cut him to pieces, and anoint him, his portion with the hypocrites, there shall be weeping and gnashing of teeth.”
You will hear in many places that this story from the Gospels refers to a “servant”, but actually, the original word in the bible is “doulou”, Ancient Greek for slave.
The New Testament proclaims that Christians are slaves of Jesus, not servants of Jesus. When Ross Douthat cites Bible passages from the New Testament that warn that Jesus is coming back, so you had better be ready, Douthat is endorsing the idea that people should make themselves into slaves to Christian churches, proxies for Jesus.
Bible verses like this were used to justify slavery in the American South as a Christian practice. Ross Douthat is endorsing that perspective when he uses these Gospel verses as the culminating argument of his book.
Jesus will cut you into pieces. That's not the only place in the Gospels that Jesus threatens to cut people to pieces for disobeying him.
Gone is the Jesus who earlier on in the gospel's refused to cast the first stone. Now Jesus is the one throwing stones. Jesus is the one cutting people up, killing them for disobeying him.
That line that Ross Douthat wrote: “but from the one who has not, even what he has will be taken away,” that's Jesus saying he's going to take things away from people, and what is the very next line in the Gospel of Luke, chapter 19? It a threat of murder by Jesus.
“Those my enemies, who do not want me to rule over them, bring them here, and kill them, before me.”
In the gospel of Luke, we have Jesus saying that things are going to be like in the days of Noah. What are what are the things that we know about Noah? The days of Noah were the days when God killed, when God killed because he just didn't like people. He didn't like what people were. He didn't like people doing what they wanted instead of what he wanted them to do.
The God of Christianity is a God who never keeps his promises. Remember, back from Genesis and the story of Noah, what did God promise never to do again? He said, I'm never going to kill all the people on earth again. I'm never gonna do that.
Now, in Christianity, God is saying, yeah, I'm going to do that whole Noah thing all over again. We're going to kill, kill a lot of people, kill, kill, kill. We're going to kill because people are disagreeing with his orders.
People outside of Christianity ask all the time, why would an all powerful God create such a difficult, harsh, unforgiving, unloving system?
This god, and the people who choose to follow him, they seem to revel in the punishment of slaves. They seem to thrive on violence and pain, on the threat of casting people out into exile at best, and into torture, into absolute death, as punishment.
It’s sick, manipulative cruelty, this idea that Jesus is the master of the house and has left, but is going to come back at any time, never going to tell you what time that is, but you have to be ready, eternally ready, always ready just in case he's looking, just in case he's watching, and if he finds that you're doing something he doesn't approve of, he's going to whip you, or he's going to cut you into pieces, kill you.
Think about what it would be like to actually live in that kind of house. It's a house of terror. It's a house run by a narcissistic maniac you can never trust. You can never relax, you can never feel at peace in that house. That is the house of Jesus.
It's a house that he's abandoned. Jesus abandoned his responsibilities over his own house for two thousand years. Jesus has been gone from that house, and where did he go?
If it was an actual house and not the metaphor of the house as the universe, well, he might just go down the street to go to the market, to pick up some chickens or some vegetables or some tools or something, and he'd come right back. Maybe he'd be gone a week or two and then return, but not for this long, not for years and years.
The last thing Jesus did is to leave his slaves with a message of terror that unless they do exactly what he wants, he's going to kill them all. He's going to beat them to a pulp, make them feel pain, and he expects them to just wait while he doesn't take care of them. He leaves them to starve for years and expects everyone to remain obedient to him during that time.
That's what it would be like if it was an actual house, but really, this is a metaphor for the entire world. Jesus left the world. So where did Jesus go? Where has Jesus been all this time?
If you believe this story, he’s just been absent, but where? Has he been outside the universe, in another pocket universe to start up another torture dungeon somewhere else?
It's cruel. It's arbitrary. It's insane, this idea that we all have to live our entire lives in terror of this god, that he's going to hurt us unless we obey, unless we give our entire lives to him, without any reasonable sign that actually we're going to be paid off for it in the end.
So what's the one thing that they can hold on to in Christianity? The one thing they hold on to is the idea that other people are going to be punished. Ross Douthat people are going to get what's coming to them because they don't obey. They don't obey authority.
That's really what this is all about, in the end, this morality of punishment and torture and threats of killing people who just want to live their lives, their own way. It's a worship of totalitarian barbarity, of cruelty, of violence.
Why is Ross Douthat choosing that religion? It's because he values those kinds of things over a life of freedom. He would rather live in servitude, to a tyrannical warlord, than to make choices for himself.
The rest of us see that. We see that in the government that his religion has given to the United States of America, one that is completely random and chaotic, in which our president doesn't take the time to actually take care of people. He builds ballrooms and monumental arches for himself instead. He's more interested in his own golf courses than he is to the United States of America. He doesn't care about this nation. He doesn't care about the prices going up. He doesn't care about the consequences of his arbitrary actions.
What Donald Trump has built, in this Christian Nationalist government, is like what Jesus promises to build. It’s an arbitrary, totalitarian, authoritarian regime in which everyone obeys and goes along because they live in fear. They're afraid of being punished if they step out of line.
This America that Christian Nationalism has built, it's miserable. Ross Douthat may criticize it around the margins, but in the end, it is exactly the model that he is arguing for here at the end of his book.
Ross Douthat is saying that gosh, he sure would like Christianity to be different. He sure would like it to be more forgiving, to be more open-minded, but it isn't, and he's too afraid to stand up for what's right, for basic human dignity and freedom, and so he's going along with it.
You know, not everyone is going to go along with it. That's why not everyone believes Ross Douthat.